The Few & the Many: Free Trade, Outsourcing, & Communication


Have you noticed that some sound ideas get bad publicity? Two I have in mind are outsourcing and free trade.

No doubt you could name others, but looking at these two initiatives helps us understand a communication challenge for many companies and not-for-profit organizations.

Free trade and outsourcing both produce a few (well, relatively few) big losers, and many (very many) small winners.

More specifically, free trade leads to big losses for a relatively small number of companies and their employees. Companies can go out of business or be forced to drastically restructure; employees can lose their jobs. The adjustment pains they suffer are very real and very significant.

On the other hand, all consumers in a country that adopts free trade are winners. In other words, just about everybody. The gains for each person are small, yet, taken together those gains far outweigh the losses suffered by the losers. And the gains keep paying dividends year after year.

The story is much the same for outsourcing. A few employees take a very big hit, losing their jobs. At the same time, though, a lot of other employees get to keep their jobs because their companies become stronger. A few suffer for the many.

Which do you hear more about? You hear far more about the losers, of course. Why? Well, as a former news writer and announcer I can tell you that losers holler louder and longer. They actively seek media coverage. And that's not all: stories about layoffs have an inherent drama that stories about the preservation of jobs just can't match.

In addition, small-scale winners often don't know they've won, how they've won, or what they've won, so they don't march in protest or call news conferences. Add to that the general principle that good news isn't big news.

What do you do if you face a decision leading to many small winners and a few big losers? First, hammer away at the context, at the circumstances that drive the decision. For example, don't announce to employees that a new piece of equipment that does the work of three people will make you more efficient. Rather, explain the competitive pressures that force greater efficiency, and the consequences of failing to meet those pressures.

Don't assume everyone shares your knowledge. Few stakeholders understand the broader picture, and even if they could, the pressure of day-to-day events may keep them focused on just one piece of it. It's essential to start with as few assumptions as possible.

Communicate frequently: in advance, during, and afterward. Explain the problem, outline the options, list the decision criteria, announce the solution, and report on how well the solution has worked. Or not worked, which becomes the new problem.

You won't convince everyone your decision is the right one, but you might convince enough people to make further progress possible.

In summary, when a few people suffer big losses and many others make small gains, you can expect the losers to complain very loudly, and the winners to say little or nothing. To deal with these situations, communicate frequently and carefully.

Robert F. Abbott writes and publishes Abbott's Communication Letter. If you subscribe, you will receive, at no charge, communication tips that help you lead or manage more effectively. You can get more information here: http://www.Communication-Newsletter.com







Related News




GameStop Board Announces Senior Management Reorganization - MarketWatch

GameStop Board Announces Senior Management Reorganization
MarketWatch -14 hours ago
approved a reorganization of the senior management structure in light of the company's tremendous growth, impressive continued worldwide brand expansion and ...
GameStop reorganizes top management in light of growthBizjournals.com
all 44 news articles

Teamsters and Waste Management Agree to Re-Enter Negotiations - MarketWatch

Teamsters and Waste Management Agree to Re-Enter Negotiations
MarketWatch -5 hours ago
"Today our union received correspondence from a representative at Waste Management to request a return to negotiations and resolve the outstanding ...

Hartford Investment Management Company Names Greg McGreevey Chief ... - MarketWatch

Hartford Investment Management Company Names Greg McGreevey Chief ...
MarketWatch -Aug 28, 2008
He joined the firm on August 25 from ING Investment Management and reports to David Znamierowski, president of Hartford Investment Management Company. ...

FACTBOX-India's top 5 fund management joint ventures - Reuters

Reuters

FACTBOX-India's top 5 fund management joint ventures
Reuters -16 hours ago
DE: Quote, Profile, Research, Stock Buzz) said on Friday it expects to sign a deal within weeks to set up an asset management joint venture in India, ...
Waste Management says US asks for more Republic bid infoReuters
Scotiabank keen on wealth management, mum on dealsReuters
KKR in lead to buy Lehman asset management : reportReuters
Reuters
all 1,706 news articles

Hedge Funds Step in to Help the Hexion-Huntsman Deal - Wall Street Journal Blogs

Dividend.com

Hedge Funds Step in to Help the Hexion-Huntsman Deal
Wall Street Journal Blogs, NY -13 hours ago
Highfields Capital Management helped break a logjam at the buyout of Clear Channel Communications, offering concessions that resulted in revised terms that ...
Huntsman welcomes shareholder plan to save buyoutReuters
Funds plan investment to push Huntsman deal throughMarketWatch
Hexion declines financing from Huntsman holdersForbes
Wall Street Journal - New York Times
all 54 news articles

Teamsters, Waste Management remain at odds as garbage piles up - Bizjournals.com

Teamsters, Waste Management remain at odds as garbage piles up
Bizjournals.com, NC -11 hours ago
Teamsters Local 200 has refused to resume bargaining negotiations with Waste Management Inc. as a strike of garbage collection workers enters its fourth day ...
Teamsters, Waste Management To Re-Enter NegotiationsWISN.com
Local 200 Teamsters Strike Waste ManagementThe Daily Kenoshan
New talks seen in Milwaukee area garbage strikeCNNMoney.com
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel - Journal Times
all 62 news articles

Flint Media Changes Name to RiverRun Resources Inc. and Appoints ... - MarketWatch

Flint Media Changes Name to RiverRun Resources Inc. and Appoints ...
MarketWatch -13 hours ago
VANCOUVER, BC, Aug 29, 2008 (MARKET WIRE via COMTEX) -- Flint Media Group, Inc. (FMGO) announces it has completed a merger with RiverRun Resources Inc., ...

The GEO Group Announces Discontinuation of Management Contract in ... - MarketWatch

The GEO Group Announces Discontinuation of Management Contract in ...
MarketWatch -10 hours ago
announced today that it has decided to discontinue its contract with Delaware County, Pennsylvania for the management of the county-owned 1883-bed George W. ...

ABN AMRO Asset Management Canada Limited embraces their official ... - MarketWatch

ABN AMRO Asset Management Canada Limited embraces their official ...
MarketWatch -11 hours ago
TORONTO, Aug 29, 2008 (BUSINESS WIRE) -- ABN AMRO Asset Management Canada Limited is pleased to announce their official name change to Fortis Investment ...

1st Century Bank Expands Relationship Management Team - CNNMoney.com

1st Century Bank Expands Relationship Management Team
CNNMoney.com -4 hours ago
"Christopher is a talented business executive who possesses strong relationship management, finance, and banking skills. His respective areas of expertise ...